a royal refusal

Kate Middleton apologizes to a fan over a strict royal rule she can’t break


The Princess of Wales had to politely refuse a fan's request during her visit to Mumbai with Prince William, and the reason involves a longstanding royal family protocol


The Prince and Princess of Wales are visiting Mumbai to attend the sixth annual Earthshot Prize Summit. © WireImage
Shirley GomezSenior Writer
NOVEMBER 17, 2026 10:08 AM EST

Kate Middleton may be one of the most recognizable women in the world, but even the Princess of Wales must follow rules that can make meeting royal fans awkward.

During her visit to Mumbai, India, on November 16, 2026, the 44-year-old royal found herself in an uncomfortable but familiar situation when a young admirer asked for her autograph. Rather than signing, Kate offered a polite apology. "Sorry, I can't sign," the Princess of Wales said, according to a video shared by our sister magazine, HELLO! 

Prince William, Prince of Wales and Catherine, Princess of Wales arrive at the Earthshot Prize on November 17, 2026 in Mumbai, India. © Samir Husssein/WireImage
Prince William, Prince of Wales and Catherine, Princess of Wales arrive at the Earthshot Prize on November 17, 2026 in Mumbai, India.

The brief exchange happened as Kate and Prince William greeted well-wishers who had gathered to watch the couple participate in a street cricket event alongside Indian cricket legend Sachin Tendulkar.

While Tendulkar happily signed autographs for excited spectators, Kate had to decline a similar request. However, the Princess didn't simply walk away. She continued engaging with the crowd, showing that a royal refusal doesn't have to mean an unfriendly encounter.

Sachin Tendulkar and Catherine, Princess of Wales during a visit to the Ballard Estate on November 16, 2026 in Mumbai, India. © WireImage
Sachin Tendulkar and Catherine, Princess of Wales during a visit to the Ballard Estate on November 16, 2026 in Mumbai, India.

Why Kate Middleton Cannot Sign Autographs for Royal Fans

Although celebrities routinely sign photographs, books, and memorabilia, members of the British royal family generally avoid giving autographs to members of the public. The reason is largely about security.

Royal signatures could potentially be copied and used for forgery, which is why the monarchy has traditionally discouraged public autograph signing. The protocol applies to senior members of the royal family, including Kate and Prince William.

The Prince and Princess of Wales are visiting Mumbai to attend the sixth annual Earthshot Prize Summit. © WireImage
The Prince and Princess of Wales are visiting Mumbai to attend the sixth annual Earthshot Prize Summit.

That doesn't mean royals never put pen to paper. They regularly sign official documents, correspondence, and guest books during formal engagements.

But when it comes to autograph requests from fans, the expectation is different. Instead, royals may offer a handshake, pose for a photograph, or spend a few moments chatting with admirers.

Throughout their 3-day visit the royal couple will carry out engagements celebrating sustainability, innovation and the relationship between India and the United Kingdom. © WireImage
Throughout their 3-day visit the royal couple will carry out engagements celebrating sustainability, innovation and the relationship between India and the United Kingdom.

Kate offered the young fan a friendly handshake during the Mumbai encounter. A personal interaction is welcome, even when a signature isn't an option.

Kate Middleton Has Apologized for the Same Royal Rule Before

Interestingly, the Mumbai encounter wasn't the first time Kate had to explain the autograph restriction. During a visit to Wales in February 2026, a man approached the Princess of Wales holding a pen and hoping to receive her signature.

The Prince and Princess of Wales are visiting Mumbai to attend the sixth annual Earthshot Prize Summit. © WireImage
The Prince and Princess of Wales are visiting Mumbai to attend the sixth annual Earthshot Prize Summit.

Kate responded with another courteous refusal. "I can't sign things, I'm so sorry. I can shake your hand, though," she told him. The exchange ended with a hug before Kate waved goodbye and went on to greet other members of the public.

Kate Middleton Once Found a Creative Way Around the Autograph Rule

Kate has even come up with an imaginative alternative when children have asked her to sign something. During a Chelsea Flower Show engagement with schoolchildren, the Princess was asked to sign drawings. She explained the restriction in language the children could understand. "My name's Catherine," she told them, adding, "I'm not allowed to write my signature."

But that didn't mean she couldn't leave them with something special. Kate offered a clever alternative. "I can't write my name, but I can draw," she explained. Instead of signing, she reportedly drew a flower for one child and a pond surrounded by plants for another.

Catherine, Princess Of Wales attends the 2023 Chelsea Flower Show © WireImage
Catherine, Princess Of Wales attends the 2023 Chelsea Flower Show

The gesture allowed the children to take home something personally created by the Princess without requiring her to break the autograph convention. 

Kate Middleton and Prince William's India Visit Marks a Major Royal Milestone

Beyond the autograph incident, Kate's appearance in Mumbai represents an important moment for the Prince and Princess of Wales. The couple traveled to India for the sixth annual Earthshot Prize awards, an environmental initiative founded by Prince William to recognize and support innovative solutions to major global challenges.

The visit marks their first joint international royal tour in four years, following their trip to Boston in 2022. It is also their first overseas tour together since Kate publicly revealed her cancer diagnosis in March 2024.

The Prince and Princess of Wales are visiting Mumbai to attend the sixth annual Earthshot Prize Summit. © WireImage
The Prince and Princess of Wales are visiting Mumbai to attend the sixth annual Earthshot Prize Summit.

The Princess underwent treatment that year and announced in January 2025 that she was in remission.

Kate Middleton Joins Prince William for Cricket in Mumbai

The couple's Mumbai itinerary included a lively cricket engagement with Sachin Tendulkar, one of India's most celebrated sporting figures. Kate joined in the activity, showing off her cricket skills while interacting with children and spectators.

For the occasion, she wore a pistachio-green Veronica Beard jacket paired with white Alexander McQueen trousers.

Catherine, Princess of Wales plays gully cricket during a visit to the Ballard Estate on November 16, 2026 in Mumbai, India. © WireImage
Catherine, Princess of Wales plays gully cricket during a visit to the Ballard Estate on November 16, 2026 in Mumbai, India.

The relaxed outfit was a practical choice for an outdoor sporting event while maintaining the polished style associated with the Princess of Wales. After taking part in the game, Kate reportedly joked, "I think we need more practice," according to The Telegraph.

The couple also experienced Mumbai's public transportation system during their visit, traveling on the city's Aqua Line metro.

 The royal couple are in the city to attend events linked to the sixth annual Earthshot Prize Summit and Awards. © Anadolu via Getty Images
Prince William, Prince of Wales, and Catherine, Princess of Wales, travel on the metro from Vidhan Bhavan station

Kate later changed into a cobalt-blue Roksanda dress that she had previously worn to Wimbledon in 2025. 

Do Other Members of the Royal Family Ever Break the Autograph Rule?

Although the royal family's approach to autographs is well established, there have been occasional exceptions. King Charles III, for example, reportedly made an unusual exception in 2010 while visiting a family in Cornwall whose home had been damaged by flooding.

According to E! News, the then-Prince of Wales was asked whether he could provide an autograph for a young boy named Tom. Rather than refusing, Charles reportedly wrote "Charley 2010" on a piece of paper.

Britain's King Charles III reacts, as he visits the Gardens Antigua Barbuda Horticultural Society© Getty Images
Britain's King Charles

He also apologized for his handwriting, explaining that he wasn't accustomed to writing while standing.