a surprising turn

Clara Chía vs. Jordi Martín: Who won the court battle?


Here's why the judges ruled in his favor and what happens next




Gerard Pique was seen enjoying a romantic getaway in Venice, Italy, with girlfriend Clara Chia Marti. The former footballer was photographed aboard a boat as the couple took in the sights along the Grand Canal during their trip through the city. Pique and Clara have been linked since 2022 following his split from singer-songwriter Shakira.
***
Gerard Piqué fue visto disfrutando de una escapada romántica en Venecia, Italia, junto a su novia Clara Chía Martí. El exfutbolista fue fotografiado a bordo de una embarcación mientras la pareja recorría los paisajes del Gran Canal durante su visita a la ciudad. Piqué y Clara mantienen una relación desde 2022 tras su separación de la cantante y compositora Shakira.© Backgrid UK/The Grosby Group
Shirley GomezSenior Writer
NOVEMBER 18, 2026 3:05 PM EST

After more than three years of legal drama, the court battle involving Gerard Piqué's girlfriend, Clara Chía Martí, and Spanish paparazzi photographer Jordi Martín has taken a surprising turn.

Jordi Martín has emerged victorious in the latest ruling.

Clara Chía looks downcast in Barcelona © Grosby Group
Clara Chía looks downcast in Barcelona

On November 18, 2026, reports confirmed that the Provincial Court of Barcelona had overturned Martín's previous conviction for harassment and psychological injury involving Clara Chía.

The decision reversed a June 2024 judgment that sentenced the photographer to one year in prison and ordered him to compensate Piqué's girlfriend.

Martín, who has repeatedly defended his work as legitimate photojournalism, celebrated the decision on Instagram, declaring that he had won his legal battle.

Pique and Clara have been linked since 2022 following his split from singer-songwriter Shakira.© Backgrid UK/The Grosby Group
Clara Chia Marti captured in Italy by a paparazzi

However, the ruling does not necessarily mean the dispute is permanently closed. Clara Chía retains the possibility of challenging the decision before Spain's Supreme Court under the applicable legal procedures. 

Why Did Clara Chía Sue Paparazzi Jordi Martín?

The legal dispute began in 2023, when Clara Chía filed a complaint against Jordi Martín with the Catalan police, known as the Mossos d'Esquadra.

The photographer had closely followed the relationship between Clara Chía and former FC Barcelona star Gerard Piqué, particularly after the footballer's highly publicized separation from Colombian singer Shakira in June 2022.


Gerard Pique and Girlfriend Clara Chia © Splash News/The Grosby Group
Gerard Pique and Girlfriend Clara Chia

As Piqué's new relationship attracted international attention, Martín became one of the photographers documenting the couple's public appearances.

Clara Chía alleged that his repeated attempts to photograph her went beyond ordinary media coverage and amounted to harassment.

According to evidence presented during the proceedings, she experienced anxiety and significant disruptions to her daily life. She reportedly stopped participating in certain social activities, avoided going to the gym, changed some of her routines, and sought psychological treatment. Her complaint ultimately resulted in criminal proceedings against Martín.

Clara Chia was photographed in late January following Pique's departure to the US© Jordi Martin/The Grosby Group
Clara Chia was photographed in late January following Pique's departure to the US

In June 2024, Barcelona's Criminal Court No. 14 sided with Clara Chía, finding the photographer guilty of harassment and causing psychological harm. 

What Was Jordi Martín's Original Sentence in 2024?

The original judgment was a significant victory for Clara Chía. The court imposed several penalties on the photographer, including one year in prison: Six months for harassment and another six months for the injury offense.

€10,000 in compensation for moral damages, €3,130 in medical expenses related to the harm alleged in the proceedings, and a restraining order preventing Martín from approaching within 1,000 meters of Clara Chía or communicating with her for 18 months.

Clara Chía looks downcast in Barcelona © Grosby Group
Clara Chía photographed alone by Jordi Martín

However, Martín challenged the judgment, maintaining that his objective was to obtain photographs for publication rather than intimidate or harm Clara Chía.

The Spanish prosecution service also supported his acquittal. That appeal ultimately changed the outcome of the case. 

Why Did the Barcelona Court Overturn Jordi Martín's Conviction?

The latest ruling focused on whether Martín's conduct met the legal requirements for criminal harassment. According to Spanish newspaper El País, the appellate judges examined 17 documented incidents over approximately nine months.

They found that Clara Chía was accompanied by Gerard Piqué during most of those encounters.


Despite months of silence, public speculation, and dramatic headlines, Gerard Piqué and Clara Chía are walking their path.© Jordi Martin/The Grosby Group
Jordi Martin captures Piqué and Clara Chia in 2025

Only four incidents involved Chía without the former footballer. The court determined that the evidence did not establish the persistent, repeated targeting of Clara Chía individually that would be required to uphold the criminal harassment conviction.

The judges also concluded that the changes to her lifestyle could not be attributed specifically to Martín's actions. Instead, they considered the intense public attention surrounding her relationship with Piqué to be an important factor. The court additionally found insufficient evidence to establish the necessary causal connection between Martín's conduct and the psychological injuries alleged in the case.

Importantly, the judges did not conclude that every action taken by the photographer was acceptable. They acknowledged that some of his methods may have been intrusive and potentially exceeded the limits of press freedom.

Nevertheless, the court determined that the conduct did not satisfy the requirements for criminal punishment and suggested that civil proceedings could be a more appropriate avenue for addressing such behavior. 

Jordi Martín Celebrates His Legal Victory on Instagram

Following the appellate court's decision, Jordi Martín shared a statement on social media celebrating his acquittal. The photographer expressed relief that the conviction had been overturned and described the outcome as recognition of his professional work.

In his statement, he maintained that photographing public figures in public places constitutes journalism rather than harassment.

View post on Instagram
 

He also acknowledged that his profession can make celebrities uncomfortable, while insisting that discomfort alone should not automatically result in criminal punishment.

Martín's statement included a particularly direct declaration: "He ganado a Clara Chia en los juzgados. Me han absuelto. Aquí termina una batalla judicial." Translated into English, the photographer said he had defeated Clara Chía in court, had been acquitted, and considered the legal battle over.

Is the Clara Chía and Jordi Martín Legal Battle Officially Over?

Although Jordi Martín has publicly declared the dispute finished, the Provincial Court of Barcelona has acquitted him of the criminal offenses for which he was convicted in 2024.

View post on Instagram
 

That means the previous criminal conviction has been overturned. However, reports indicate that Clara Chía can still seek review before Spain's Supreme Court through a limited appeal on points of law.