Skip to main contentSkip to footer

LOL

Brooks Nader blocked her sister after she exposed her roster with Carlos Alcaraz


Brooks is building her own athletic roster


Grace and Brooks Nader, Carlos Alcaraz© Getty
Jovita TrujilloSenior Writer
OCTOBER 1, 2025 5:30 PM EDT

Brooks Nader’s life was put on blast lately, and her own sister is partly to blame. After Grace Ann Nader exposed her roster, her big sister blocked her. 

Grace Ann Nader and Brooks Nader © Jose Perez/Bauer-Griffin
Grace spilled all the tea about her sister

It all started when Grace Ann spilled on Page Six Radio that her sister had “a little roster” of athletes from “every field and court,” teasing that one of their names “rhymes with winner.” 

Brooks later joked she wanted to punch her sibling for saying too much, but in September, Grace confirmed rumors that Brooks was dating Carlos Alcaraz. “The rumors are true," she said, clarifying, “Dating is such a loose term. But I do know he’s the man of the hour.”

Brooks' sister said Carlos is the man of the hour© Getty
Brooks' sister said Carlos is the man of the hour

The sisterly overshare got her on the block list. Grace was on the Not Skinny But Not Fat podcast when Amanda Hirsch asked, “Did she really block you? She told me she blocked you." “She blocked me,” Grace confirmed. 

But this isn't something new, their sister Sarah Jane explained, “They block each other all the time.”

Grace Ann Nader, Brooks Nader, and Sarah Jane Nader© Gotham
Grace Ann Nader, Brooks Nader, and Sarah Jane Nader

According to Hirsch, the whole thing went down right after Grace Ann spilled to E! News about Brooks’ dating life. When she called Brooks to have the sisters on the podcast, the 28-year-old told her, "Oh my God, I’m so mad at [Grace Ann] right now." "I was like, ‘Wait, that’s what’s happening right now? Could you connect me to them?’” Hirsch recalled. “She’s blocked right now, but hold on, I’ll connect you,” Brooks said before looping her sister in.

Grace admitted the tension lasted a while. “She didn’t speak to me for a while,” she said. But the sisters ended up back in each other’s orbit when Brooks’ publicist asked Grace to sit mic’d in the audience at Watch What Happens Live. “I was like, ‘Oh, my gosh. This is gonna be the death of me,” Grace thought.

Winner Carlos Alcaraz of Spain and runner-up Jannik Sinner of Italy pose with trophies following the Men's Singles Final match© Getty
Carlos and Jannik were sharing more than the court

Sure enough, Andy Cohen wasted no time asking Brooks about Page Six’s report that she was dating both Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner during the US Open. Brooks played it coy: “A lady never kisses and tells, especially twice. That’s just not nice.” Keeping up the hilarious sisterly oversharing dynamic, Grace Ann quipped from the audience, “Especially not to her other boyfriend.”

At the end of the day, Brooks seems unfazed by the chatter. If the relationships aren’t official, she’s just playing the same game men do all the time. 

© ¡HOLA! Reproduction of this article and its photographs in whole or in part is prohibited, even when citing their source.