OMG

Brooks Nader was dating Carlos Alcaraz and his runner-up Jannik Sinner at the same time

Haven't we seen this movie before?

Brooke Nader, Carlos Alcaraz, Jannik Sinner

SEPTEMBER 11, 2025 8:06 PM EDTSEP 11, 2025, 8:06 PM EDT

Brooks Nader is putting new meaning to the word "roster." The reality star is now smack in the middle of a juicy tennis love triangle. After news broke that she is dating US Open Men's singles champion Carlos Alcaraz, she's now been linked to his runner-up, Jannik Sinner.

The news, straight out of a literal movie, aka The Challengers, comes from Page Six. A source told the outlet she was dating the number 1 and number 2 seeds at the same time during the US Open.

Winner Carlos Alcaraz of Spain and runner-up Jannik Sinner of Italy pose with trophies following the Men's Singles Final match

The speculation kicked off when Brooks’ sister Grace Ann spilled on Page Six Radio that her big sis was juggling “a little roster” of athletes from “every field and court” before dropping the not-so-subtle hint that one suitor’s name “rhymes with winner.” Brooks, clearly caught off guard, threatened to punch her sibling later for oversharing, but the damage was done.

Brooks herself played coy when Jimmy Kimmel pressed her about Sinner, teasing, “Is this, like, an interrogation? I’m so scared right now… You’re close. You’re warm.”

You may also like:

Brooks' sister said Carlos is the man of the hour

Fast-forward, and she was spotted front row at Alcaraz’s match on August 31, then cheering again as the Spanish star took down Sinner in the finals.

Brooks Nader at the US Open at Arthur Ashe Stadium on August 31, 2025

Days later, Grace Ann spoke on he sister's love life again, this time confirming the rumors between her and Alcaraz. She told E! “The rumors are true.” However, she clarified, “Dating is such a loose term. But I do know he’s the man of the hour.”

While it sounds dramatic, it's no different than what a lot of men do, especially athletes. Plus, if none of them are in an "official" monogamous relationship, Brooks can date as many guys as she wants.

It's not the first time Brooks' messy dating life has made headlines. Earlier this year, in April, she called it quits with Dancing with the Stars pro Gleb Savchenko. Except, Savchenko said, he only found out through the press. “I was surprised to learn through article(s) published today… that Brooks has ended our relationship,” Gleb told Page Six.

Gleb and Brooks leave Sartiano's Restaurant on March 31, 2025 in New York City — Gleb and Brooks called it quits in April 2025 to his surprise

What's kind of incredible is that all of this is happening while she is still legally married. She said "I do" to William Haire on December 15, 2019, and although they announced their split in May 2024, they have yet to legally file for divorce. In January, she joked on TikTok, “Plot twist: I’m still legally married.”