Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O’Connor spark engagement rumors during Italian getaway © Backgrid UK/The Grosby Group

wedding bells

Is Joe Manganiello engaged to Caitlin O’Connor after Sofia Vergara split? See the diamond ring

The pair is celebrating their union in Italy with a romantic vacation


Senior Writer
JUNE 30, 2025 5:34 PM EDT

Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O’Connor’s romantic Italian escape is making headlines, and not just for the scenic views and historical landmarks. The couple was spotted hand-in-hand this week in the cliffside town of Taormina, Sicily, and eagle-eyed fans couldn’t help but notice the sparkling diamond ring on Caitlin’s left hand.

The actress and TV host turned heads during a cozy dinner date at the exclusive Le Naumachie restaurant, where she was seen flashing the dazzling ring while resting her chin on her hand and gazing at Manganiello. 

© Backgrid UK/The Grosby Group
Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O’Connor spark engagement rumors during Italian getaway

The romantic outing sparked speculation that the two may already be engaged, while no confirmation has been made. After dinner, the pair, joined by their beloved dog Bubbles, browsed a local ceramics shop before returning to the San Domenico Palace Hotel, the same resort featured in 'The White Lotus.'

© Backgrid UK/The Grosby Group
Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O’Connor spark engagement rumors during Italian getaway

Caitlin looked radiant in a plunging summer dress with cap sleeves, a ruby pendant, and wedges, while Joe kept it relaxed in a short-sleeved patterned shirt and dark pants, with his signature man-bun and beard.

© Backgrid UK/The Grosby Group
Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O’Connor spark engagement rumors during Italian getaway

This marks another romantic chapter for the couple, who first went public at the end of 2023 following Joe’s split from Sofia Vergara. The 'Magic Mike' star and the 'Winning Time' actress were reportedly introduced in a hot tub at an unofficial premiere afterparty, and have been inseparable ever since.

© Backgrid UK/The Grosby Group
Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O’Connor spark engagement rumors during Italian getaway

“They weren’t expecting for things to get serious so quickly but it’s only a good thing,” a source previously told People. “They’re super, super happy together.” While Manganiello hasn’t addressed the engagement rumors, the pair’s affectionate display, and diamond ring have people talking.

© Backgrid UK/The Grosby Group
Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O’Connor spark engagement rumors during Italian getaway

The sighting comes two years after Joe finalized his divorce from Vergara, whom he married in 2015. Caitlin, 18 years younger, was said to have moved in with Joe earlier this year. “They’re very much in love,” a source told TMZ at the time.

© Backgrid UK/The Grosby Group
Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O’Connor spark engagement rumors during Italian getaway

© ¡HOLA! Reproduction of this article and its photographs in whole or in part is prohibited, even when citing their source.